Appeal Evaluation: Imagine Learning EL Education (1st Edition) is a core program that meets the threshold in 5 of the 6 categories and has 3 red flags. However, one reporting category, Phonological Awareness, is showing the need for supplemental support. The program meets the criteria set forth in SB 127 for core curriculum. Please read the comments throughout the checklist and in the “Red Flags” section for clarification and additional information. To see the completed checklist and score, please visit here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GtryRBOX053QUR4qrE-oXniyDUCuo7Cy/view?usp=sharing Original Review: Imagine Learning EL Education K-5 2022 is a core curriculum program that is not being recommended due to 5 red flags. In order to be considered recommended, no more than 3 red flags are allowable to meet the SB 127 criteria as seen in the checklist provided here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1U_ApIknsqlas9LeDeqBaWt-yuAhzwp8T/view?usp=sharing