The PAF Teacher Handbook is a core supplemental phonics program that is not being recommended due to having 9 out of 11 red flags in the phonics section. In order to be considered recommended, no more than 3 red flags are allowable as seen in the checklist provided here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1aRmWLCPLZCcOodvLQ7dw2NNGrtUEYmN7/view?usp=sharing. Appealed Evaluation: PAF Reading Program (2023) is a supplemental program for phonics. PAF Reading meets the threshold in phonics with 91%. It also has 1 red flag. The program meets the criteria set forth in SB 127 for phonics for tier 1 instruction. To see the checklist, notes, and score, please visit here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tURuxXTHT5sraczZ9CuiGu1dhiIPnH-5/view?usp=sharing